The Long Simmer

Stew recipes were pressed into clay nearly 4,000 years ago. America's bowl of meet and potatoes has a history of its own.

12:30 p.m. Nov. 21, 2026

How Beef Stew Found Its Way to the American Table

DUANE CROSS
MCO Publisher•Editor

A good pot of beef stew can go wrong before the lid ever goes on. Crowd too much chuck into a skillet, and the meat steams instead of browns. Give the meat some elbow room and let that crust develop. Now you've got the beginnings of a respectable supper. Those brown bits stuck to the bottom of the skillet? Don't you dare wash them away. That's flavor waiting for a splash of broth.

From there, patience takes over. Chuck roast needs a long, lazy simmer before it quits putting up a fight. Add the potatoes too early, and they'll disappear into the gravy before the meat gets tender. Any cook who's made that mistake remembers it the next time.

People have been simmering meat in pots for thousands of years. Some of the oldest surviving written recipes in human history describe dishes remarkably similar to modern stews.

A history written in clay

Around 1730 B.C., cooks in ancient Mesopotamia, in what is now Iraq, recorded recipes on clay tablets. Preserved in Yale University's Babylonian Collection, those tablets offer a glimpse into what people were eating nearly 4,000 years ago.

Among the dishes were lamb stews, including one prepared with beets. Another combined meat with milk and grain. Researchers from Yale and Harvard recreated several of the recipes and discovered that the ancient cooks weren't particularly concerned with exact measurements. The instructions assumed whoever stood over the pot already knew something about cooking.

These weren't beef stews as Americans know them today. Some of the recipes were likely prepared for royal households or temples, a reminder that stewed meat wasn't always humble fare. But the basic cooking method was already well established, and it worked just as well for an elaborate meal as it did for feeding a family.

Over the centuries, cooks around the world developed their own versions, generally using whatever meat was available.

In Ireland, traditional stew was made with mutton or lamb. Potatoes gave the dish substance, while onions added flavor. It was the sort of filling meal that made sense in rural households where money was scarce and nobody wanted to leave the table hungry.

Hungarian cattle herders took a different approach. Working on the open plains, they cooked beef in large kettles suspended over fires. Their dish, known as goulash, began as a simple preparation of meat and onions. Paprika came later, after peppers from the Americas became established in Hungarian cooking.

The French developed boeuf bourguignon, a beef stew slowly cooked in red wine. The dish eventually became a symbol of French home cooking and found an enthusiastic American audience through Julia Child.

When Child's television program, The French Chef, debuted in 1963, she opened the series by preparing beef bourguignon. An old-fashioned way of cooking beef was now getting star treatment on American television.

From the cattle trail to the family table

Beef stew found plenty of room to grow in America, where practical cooking was often a necessity.

During the great cattle drives of the 1800s, chuck wagon cooks traveled with crews moving livestock across the Western plains. Their wagons carried cast-iron cookware and provisions that could survive weeks on the trail. Beef was readily available, and potatoes were useful for stretching a meal.

The Kansas Historical Society preserves a recipe for "son-of-a-gun stew," a hearty preparation that included beef and organ meats. The cook made use of whatever parts of the animal were available. It wasn't particularly glamorous, but after a long day in the saddle, a hot supper was worth plenty.

By the late 1800s, beef stew had become familiar enough to earn a place in one of America's most influential cookbooks.

Fannie Merritt Farmer included beef stew with dumplings in her 1896 Boston Cooking-School Cook Book. Her recipe called for browning the beef before simmering it for about three hours. Carrots and turnips went in during the final hour, with potatoes added near the end.

Farmer also suggested using leftover roast beef. If gravy remained from the original meal, that went into the pot, too.

That thrift helped make stew a dependable meal during the Great Depression. Families could stretch an inexpensive cut of meat with vegetables, and the broth made the servings go farther. Among itinerant workers, a variation called Mulligan stew became associated with communal meals assembled from whatever ingredients could be gathered.

The Crock-Pot changes supper

For centuries, making stew meant tending a pot over a fire or keeping watch over the stove. In 1971, Rival Manufacturing introduced the Crock-Pot, helping bring slow cooking into a new generation of American kitchens.

The electric slow cooker became especially popular with working families. Supper could be assembled before leaving home, then left to cook gently throughout the day. By evening, tougher cuts of beef had softened, and the broth had taken on the flavor of everything in the pot.

The appliance was a commercial success, but it didn't settle the old arguments about how beef stew ought to be made.

Some cooks still preferred a Dutch oven, insisting that properly browned meat and a slow simmer on the stove produced a richer result. Others were perfectly happy letting the Crock-Pot do the work.

Then there was the question of tomatoes.

Some folks wouldn't consider it beef stew without them. Others regarded that as a perfectly good way to ruin an otherwise respectable pot.

The debate continues, along with the question of whether stew belongs alongside biscuits or cornbread. There's a strong case for either, especially when the broth is thick enough to cling to a piece of bread.

Somebody will wander through the kitchen and lift the lid, even though they've already been told supper isn't ready. They'll sneak a taste of the broth and ask how much longer it's going to take. They may not like the answer, but the cook knows better than to hurry it.

The meat will be tender when it's tender. And if anything survives supper, tomorrow's already taken care of.

Prefer deer meat?
Venison makes a fine substitute

Gun deer season opened Saturday in Moore County, and some lucky hunters will soon have venison headed for the freezer. It makes a mighty fine stew, and you can substitute it for beef pound for pound. Just remember that leaner meat needs a little different treatment.

Pick the right cut. Shoulder, neck, and shank are excellent choices. These tougher cuts become tender with a long, gentle simmer.

Don't be stingy with the fat. Venison is much leaner than beef chuck. A tablespoon or two of bacon grease works wonders when browning the meat.

Give it some room. Brown the venison in batches. Crowd the skillet, and you'll steam the meat instead of developing that flavorful crust.

Take your time. Keep the broth at a gentle simmer until the meat is fork-tender. Cranking up the heat won't do venison any favors.

Mind the broth. Venison lacks the fat that gives beef stew some of its richness. A good stock helps, and a spoonful of tomato paste complements the meat's earthy flavor.

For my money, venison shoulder browned in bacon grease is hard to beat. Give it a slow simmer, and serve it with a wedge of skillet cornbread. You'll want something to sop up that gravy.

Beef Stew with Rice

• Prep time: 10 minutes
• Cook time: 40 minutes
• Servings: 4

Ingredients

1 tablespoon olive oil
1 pound beef chuck, cut into 1-inch cubes
1 onion, chopped
2 cloves garlic, minced
2 medium potatoes, diced
2 carrots, sliced
4 cups beef broth
1 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon pepper
1 cup Minute Instant White Rice
fresh parsley, for garnish

Directions

• In bottom of pressure cooker, heat oil over medium-high heat. Brown beef cubes on all sides. Remove and set aside.

• In same pot, add onion and garlic. Saute about 2 minutes.

• Return beef to pot. Add potatoes, carrots and beef broth. Season with salt and pepper.

• Close lid and set valve to sealing. Select pressure cook or manual and set timer for 35 minutes. Once cooking time is up, let pressure release naturally about 10 minutes then carefully switch valve to venting to release remaining pressure.

• Prepare rice according to package directions.

• Open lid, stir cooked rice into stew and adjust seasoning, if necessary. Garnish with parsley.

More Features

Sunday Supper: Mini Pecan Pies

Sunday Supper: Mini Pecan Pies

Small pies, big flavor. This delightfully Southern recipe turns a holiday classic into a dozen mini pecan pies made for sharing.