2010 zoning map clears way for Tolleytown quarry

BZA approved Lynchburg Stone quarry after a zoning map revealed the property was already classified heavy industrial

7:25 p.m. Nov. 17, 2026

2010 zoning map clears way for Tolleytown quarry

Lynchb urg Stone

DUANE CROSS
MCO Publisher•Editor

After months of debate over whether a rock quarry could operate on agricultural land, Moore County officials discovered something that changed the conversation: The property was already zoned for heavy industry.

The discovery cleared the way for the Board of Zoning Appeals to unanimously approve Lynchburg Stone's proposed Tolleytown quarry Tuesday, Nov. 17.

The county's adopted 2010 zoning map identifies the property at 606 Winchester Highway as I-2 Heavy Industrial. That classification became effective with the map's adoption, meaning the property was already zoned for industrial use when the quarry proposal began moving through county government earlier this year.

Chair Patrick Maynard, Peggy Sue Blackburn, Josh Cook, and Brady Goodwin attended the meeting. Houston Lindsey was absent.

An old map changes the discussion

Until Tuesday, the quarry proposal had moved through county government under the understanding that the property was zoned A-1 Agriculture-Forestry.

That assumption became an obstacle in October when an attorney representing residents opposed to the quarry challenged whether the BZA had legal authority to approve mining operations on agricultural land.

County officials said work has been done on a newer zoning map, but the adopted 2010 version remains the most recent available. Maynard told the board that research into the property's ownership history had failed to establish when the industrial designation was first assigned.

Developer Scott Fruehauf submitted a letter withdrawing the previous application, which had been filed under the assumption that the property was agriculturally zoned.

The board then considered a new request for a special exception to operate the quarry on the industrially zoned property.

Moore County's zoning ordinance specifically identifies rock quarries and mining operations among uses eligible for special exceptions in I-2 Heavy Industrial districts.

With no discussion among members, the board approved the request by unanimous voice vote.

Industrial designation changes the legal question

The discovery changes the circumstances surrounding an attorney's objection that stalled the proposal four weeks earlier.

At the Oct. 20 BZA meeting, Nashville attorney Jason Holleman, representing residents opposed to the quarry, challenged the board's authority to consider Lynchburg Stone's application.

His argument centered on two provisions of the county's zoning ordinance.

Article V, Section 5.041(C), lists uses eligible for special exceptions in the A-1 Agriculture-Forestry District. Rock quarries and mining operations are not included. Section 5.048(C), governing heavy industrial districts, specifically allows those uses to be considered for special exceptions.

Holleman maintained that the board lacked authority to approve quarrying on agricultural land. His letter also raised questions about the county's meeting-notice procedures and information residents reportedly received concerning public comments.

Rather than risk approving something the ordinance might not permit, board members unanimously postponed a decision and agreed to seek guidance from County Attorney Bill Rieder.

Fruehauf supported the delay, saying he did not want the county exposed to litigation over the project.

The adopted I-2 designation changes the basis of Holleman's principal objection, which challenged the board's authority to permit quarrying on agricultural land. However, the board did not discuss a legal opinion from Rieder during Tuesday's meeting.

A quarry with a long history

Lynchburg Stone's proposal first came before county officials March 3, when the Planning and Zoning Commission voted 5-0 to forward a preliminary site plan to the Metro Council.

The quarry itself is considerably older. Located along Highway 50 in Tolleytown, it supplied rock during construction of Tims Ford Dam in the late 1960s and remained in operation into the 1980s.

During a March 16 Metro Council discussion, members appeared receptive to allowing the quarry through a special exception rather than rezoning what they understood to be agricultural property.

Their concern centered partly on what might happen after quarry operations ended. Changing agricultural land to heavy industrial could allow other industrial uses in the future, while a special exception could authorize a particular operation without changing the underlying zoning.

The council took no formal vote, and Fruehauf subsequently pursued the special-exception process.

At the October BZA meeting, Fruehauf described plans for a relatively small operation serving Moore County farmers, homeowners, and contractors.

He estimated annual production at approximately 20,000 tons of crushed stone, with crushing equipment operating seven to 15 days a year. Blasting would occur approximately four times annually, and the business could eventually support four local jobs.

Fruehauf also told board members that Lynchburg Stone had satisfied applicable state permitting requirements and was awaiting local approval.

Approval comes without debate

The quarry proposal has prompted concerns from nearby residents about blasting, potential property damage, and increased truck traffic along Highway 50. Questions have also been raised about how quarry operations could affect groundwater in Moore County's limestone terrain.

Those concerns received considerable attention during earlier Planning and Zoning and BZA meetings, but none resurfaced Tuesday. No one spoke during the public-comment portion of the meeting, and board members did not debate the application before approving it.

Fruehauf also has adjusted his timetable. He previously hoped to have the quarry operating in January, but said Tuesday that February is now the more likely starting point for producing limestone for customers.

More Government